The Haunting Case of Jonelle Matthews: Neighbor Unveiled as Killer After 35-Year Mystery

Steve Pankey, a former political candidate, was found guilty of murdering 12-year-old Jonelle Matthews in 1984. Despite inserting himself into the investigation, Pankey's lack of remorse and callous actions revealed his sinister motive, shattering the hope of Matthews' family.

## Article:

The Haunting Case of Jonelle Matthews: Neighbor Unveiled as Killer After 35-Year Mystery

Steve Pankey, a former candidate for Idaho governor, has been found guilty of killing 12-year-old Jonelle Matthews in 1984. The case, which haunted the community for over three decades, took an unexpected turn when Pankey, a neighbor, became the prime suspect.

On December 20, 1984, Jonelle Matthews vanished from her Greeley, Colorado, home. The young girl had been last seen performing in a Christmas concert with classmates. Her disappearance sent shockwaves through the town, captivating the nation's attention when President Ronald Reagan featured her case as part of an initiative to locate missing children.

The Haunting Case of Jonelle Matthews: Neighbor Unveiled as Killer After 35-Year Mystery

Pankey, who lived across the street from Matthews, quickly inserted himself into the investigation. However, his strange behavior raised suspicions, as he seemed obsessed with the case and reached out to law enforcement unsolicited. Despite his efforts, there was no solid evidence linking him to the crime.

Over the years, Pankey's involvement in the case continued to be questioned. In 1999, he claimed that his conviction in an unrelated matter was an attempt to force him to become an informant in the Matthews disappearance. In 2010, after a spat with his former wife, he brought up the case and made disturbing statements about Matthews.

The Haunting Case of Jonelle Matthews: Neighbor Unveiled as Killer After 35-Year Mystery

In 2019, the case took a dramatic turn when human remains were discovered near Greeley. Dental records confirmed the identity of the remains as Jonelle Matthews, and her death was ruled a homicide. The evidence pointed to Pankey as the killer.

In 2022, after a retrial, Pankey was found guilty of felony murder, second-degree kidnapping, and false reporting. The jury was swayed by evidence, including Matthews' clothing and jewelry that were found with her remains, and Pankey's own writings and behaviors that suggested he harbored resentment towards the victim's family and church.

The Haunting Case of Jonelle Matthews: Neighbor Unveiled as Killer After 35-Year Mystery

The motive behind Pankey's crime may never be fully understood. However, investigators believe that Matthews became "collateral damage" in his vengeful plan against his church, which he despised. His lack of empathy and remorse for his actions highlighted the callous nature of this senseless crime.

Jonelle Matthews' sister expressed relief at Pankey's conviction, feeling safe for the first time in years. The case has also raised awareness about the importance of never giving up on solving cold cases. With the right connections and intentions, justice can prevail even decades later.

The Haunting Case of Jonelle Matthews: Neighbor Unveiled as Killer After 35-Year Mystery

The story of Jonelle Matthews and her killer, Steve Pankey, is a chilling reminder of the darkness that can lurk in our midst. Despite the passage of time, the truth will eventually surface, bringing closure to the victims' families and a sense of justice to the community.